Why the Highest Offer Doesn't Always Win in Connecticut Real Estate

October 29, 20242 min read

Think offering the most money guarantees you a home in Connecticut's hot market? Think again.

In today's competitive Connecticut real estate market, success isn't just about throwing the most money at a property. The key is positioning yourself as the "Best Buyer" - someone who presents an overwhelming offer that comprehensively meets the seller's needs.

dream to doorstep

The Art of Being the Best Buyer

Sure, price matters - you won't beat an offer that's 20% higher with good terms alone. But once you're in a competitive price range, numerous other factors come into play:

  • Inspection terms and timeline

  • Mortgage commitment dates

  • Closing flexibility

  • Earnest money deposit amount

  • Contingencies included or waived

  • Requested concessions

  • Personal property handling

These elements can tip the scales in your favor when sellers review multiple offers. It's about crafting a comprehensive package that maximizes total value.

Understanding Seller Motivations

Every seller has unique circumstances that influence their decision-making. Some sellers need a quick closing because they're carrying two mortgages. Others might need extra time to move out.

A seller with limited repair capabilities might prefer an "as-is" offer over a higher bid that demands fixes.

Ask yourself: What does the seller really need?

By tailoring your offer to match the seller's specific situation, you demonstrate flexibility and understanding—traits that can make your offer stand out.

Real Success Stories

North Haven Triumph

In North Haven, a beautiful Ranch home received 13 offers within 24 hours - half were cash offers with various terms like escalation clauses and waived inspections. Competition was fierce.

The winning bid? Actually the LOWER of two final cash offers.

Why? The buyer offered superior terms regarding inspections, contingencies, and closing dates.

Mike and Kayla's Dream Home in Wallingford

Mike and Kayla had their hearts set on a lovely home in Wallingford. Competing against multiple offers, they weren't the highest bidders. Their offer positioned them as the “Best Buyers” through:

  • Solid earnest money deposit

  • Significant cash contribution

  • Flexible inspection terms

  • Accommodating timeline

  • Strategic personal property handling

When their offer was accepted, Mike and Kayla were overjoyed. They secured their dream home not by outbidding everyone but by providing the best total value for the seller.

Making Your Offer Stand Out

Success in today's market requires understanding that being the Best Buyer means optimizing every element of your offer. While price gets you in the game, it's the complete package that wins the house.

Remember: In Connecticut’s competitive market, the strongest offer isn't always the highest - it's the one that provides maximum value and peace of mind to the seller.

Ready to Become the Best Buyer?

Have you ever wondered how to make your offer irresistible, even if you're not the highest bidder?

Let's make it happen.

Call or text me at 203-464-1479, and together we'll craft an overwhelming offer that stands out.

With my expertise, you'll navigate the Connecticut real estate market with confidence and secure the home of your dreams.

Broker / Owner of Bolduc Realty Group. Local real estate investor .

Dave Bolduc

Broker / Owner of Bolduc Realty Group. Local real estate investor .

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog